Stu’s last journal entry offers a bittersweet measure of survival. He has endured the war and made it home, but getting through it has not come without loss. That ending gives this filmed 2007 stage musical much of its emotional force: it avoids both a happy resolution and the most predictable tragic one.
The story begins years earlier, when 18-year-old Stu, a shy and sensitive Midwesterner, is drafted into the U.S. military during World War II. Out of place among the aggressively masculine men around him, he keeps his fears in a private journal. During basic training, Mitch, a handsome and self-assured fellow private, protects Stu from bullies. The two spend long nights talking, and Mitch helps him through the drills. Stu’s gratitude deepens into love.
On a train the night before deployment, a tipsy Stu finally tells Mitch how he feels. Mitch responds with a brief, tender kiss, then recoils, confused by feelings he has kept buried. He angrily cuts Stu off for crossing a line. Convinced he has ruined everything, Stu withdraws. At a military bar, he meets Artie, an older, openly queer photographer for Yank, the Army Weekly magazine. Artie recognizes a kindred spirit, takes Stu under his wing, and shows him how to navigate gay life in a military where being gay is illegal and dangerous.
Artie also helps Stu become a combat reporter. For ten months, they travel through different military sectors covering stories. Away from home, Stu explores his sexuality, but Mitch remains on his mind. When he learns that Mitch’s division is bound for the brutal Pacific theater, Stu uses his press credentials to follow him to the front. The reunion brings reconciliation and a renewed romance, away from the rules of home base. The closeness does not last untroubled: military police discover Stu’s journal.
In the 1940s, being gay could bring severe criminal penalties, including brutal interrogation and a dishonorable court martial. Stu accepts the blame to shield Mitch from being ruined. To escape prison and regain the authorities’ approval, he agrees to return to the front as a combat infantryman. He survives its horrors and eventually comes home after the war, leaving his final reflection in the journal.
The two leads have electric chemistry, and the performers make their relationship feel convincing and heartfelt. I found myself hoping they would overcome every obstacle and get their happy ending, even though the film does not offer one. I’m not usually a musical fan and fast-forwarded through the songs to stay with the story; even so, I was impressed. The musical format drags in places, and a straight play might have suited the material better, though that is only my opinion.
I appreciated the ending’s refusal to take the obvious tragic route. I’m glad I watched, and I wonder whether it is still playing somewhere. Wartime gay love stories are rare, and this one is a moving reminder of times gone by. It runs a little long as a musical, but its cast is strong. (5.5/10)