The strongest moments in Borstal Boy arrive near the end: a kiss between Brendan and Charlie, then a goodbye that makes Charlie’s quiet affection hurt. Before those scenes, the film can feel uncertain about its direction. It eventually finds an emotional center, but too late to give the whole story enough weight.
Brendan is 16 when he is caught trying to smuggle a few sticks of dynamite aboard a ship and sent to Borstal, an institution for underage detainees. There he meets Charlie, a sailor who is openly gay. Brendan insists he is not, but the two become close friends. Their time with the other boys includes a prison escape attempt that costs them close friendships, as well as a play that brings Brendan and Charlie to a kiss.
Brendan’s feelings develop in more than one direction. He falls for the governor’s daughter, while Charlie longs for him in silence. The kiss does not feel strange to Brendan; he comes to understand that he is bisexual and loves both Charlie and the girl, though his feelings for her are stronger. Charlie is released and joins his ship in Singapore. Soon afterward, word comes that he has died in the war. Brendan is devastated, but his improved behavior brings his own release soon after, and he leaves Borstal carrying his love for both a man and a girl.
I only learned at the end that the film takes its name from a book telling the true story of Brendan Behan, the Irish writer and political activist, and his time in a British labor camp. I can’t judge how faithfully the film tells that story; I know nothing about Behan, so this is only my response to the movie. It seems intended as a dreamy, romantic account of Brendan’s emotional growth, including a teenager’s awakening to his sexuality. For much of the first half, though, I wasn’t sure where it was going. The final 20 to 25 minutes are where it finally gathers force and becomes genuinely moving.
Charlie’s yearning looks and the last farewell are especially affecting, and the escape scenes bring welcome energy, capturing the boys’ desire to be free. But the film gives little space to the teenagers’ struggles, and Charlie can seem more like an afterthought than a fully developed character. There is too little intimacy between him and Brendan, and too little substance overall. Outside its late emotional payoff, the film feels like a generic made-for-TV drama: a late-blooming story with a lovely kiss and a heartbreaking goodbye, but one that remains too thin. (5/10)