Leo has always been afraid of falling for a straight man, so developing feelings for Brendan is hardly part of his plan. Brendan is a handsome, brooding Irish guy who is supposedly straight, and Leo meets him in a New Age men’s therapy group where Leo is the only gay member. That awkward attraction sets much of this lighthearted 1999 romantic comedy in motion, as it explores just how flexible and fluid modern sexual identity can be.
Brendan is initially taken aback when Leo admits his feelings to the group, but he gradually warms to him. They begin hanging out, usually at Brendan’s initiative, and eventually become a couple. Brendan has recently split from his girlfriend after seven years together, although they still run a cafe together.
Complications arrive when Brendan’s ex turns up at Leo’s place, believing he is sleeping with his neighbor and close friend Angie. Instead, she discovers that Leo was her high school sweetheart. Leo feels guilty about keeping his relationship with Brendan secret from her, but he can’t make himself confess. Finally, he brings the two together and blurts out the truth. Brendan ends their relationship immediately afterward.
The film frames all this with a surprise party for Leo’s 30th birthday, a celebration he never wanted. After opening at the party, it goes back to tell his story before returning to the present, where people from his past are back in the picture. It ends with Leo and Sally, leaving it unclear whether they actually sleep together.
Leo is openly gay and hopes to find love someday, though he isn’t actively looking for it or especially involved in the gay scene. He joins the therapy group at the urging of his war buddy. At home, his flamboyant roommate Darren is carrying on an affair with a real estate agent, an arrangement that conveniently provides access to an empty apartment. Good sex is another obvious incentive. Darren’s ongoing affair supplies plenty of comic relief throughout.
The film is best watched with its era in mind. It’s also striking now to see how many actors in smaller roles went on to become massive stars. For the most part, though, this is a low-drama story about young roommates dealing with their tangled relationships. Much of its humor comes from the men’s support group, and most of those jokes work.
I enjoyed watching Leo and Brendan’s relationship develop, but Darren gave me most of the laughs. The actor’s sharp timing and mischievous energy made me wish he had more screen time, especially when the comedy slowed down. The script stays breezy without struggling to explain everything, and the story is enjoyable enough to follow wherever it wanders.
Underneath the jokes, the characters face real struggles with the fluidity of life, love and sexuality. They stumble through a few difficulties, decide to be themselves and find happiness. How often do you see a film do that? It also brought back a sense of simpler times that I sometimes miss, when people talked, dated, hung out and interacted the old-fashioned way.
I’d first seen the film more than 20 years ago, long before I began writing reviews, and it felt like time to revisit it, as I have with a number of older movies. Most of it had slipped from my memory until the final line, “it must be a phase,” suddenly reminded me that yes, I really had watched it before. Memory is funny that way. (6/10)